I bought my 1894c back in 2009, it has the JM roll mark stamp on the barrel. It is a tack driver with Hornady 158gr. XTP's and 18gr. of Lil' gun powder at 50 yards. Dedicate one day at the range with each rifle and then make your decision. I love my 1894c, if I was in your shoes, Id keep both! :P :D...