- I don't want a semiauto, because they are too easy to shoot unintentionally
I don't want a bolt-action, because the action is cumbersome to a new shooter
I don't want a break-open, because of the repositioning each time if shooting off a rest
I have tried different sights, and different guns, and early on noticed that the newbies tend to have trouble scrunching their head down all the way to use traditional barrel-mounted sights, yet they do very well with the unusually high sights of an AR-15. I think it is because they tend to use a 'chin' weld rather than a 'cheek' weld (which even as an experienced shooter, I realized is what I do, since I prefer scopes, and many guns I've scoped lack the high comb usually recommended for scopes). So, I tried scopes on high rings like the Weaver see-through ones, and sure enough, the newbies did better with such a setup.
- Now here I might add that while I know some purists would insist that the only way to start someone out is to force them to 'do it right from the beginning', and I agree with that as far as safety issues, etc., I think that the most important thing initially is to overcome their apprehension, and their skepticism that they won't be able to shoot well. Therefore, an unintimidating type of firearm, and a setup that assures easy target hits, is my priority at first. If a good startup enables them to ENJOY shooting, they will easily develop their own 'style' later on.
So, at this point the goal is a .22 LR levergun, with a red-dot sight, set up to shoot off a rest. The short lever-throw and smooth action of my Ruger 96/22 has always made the newbies feel comfortable, and so that was my starting gun. I've used it with a TruGlo 'open' style holosight on it (has several selectable 'dots' including crosshairs, etc., and five levels of either green or red, so works in pretty much any light/background), and I have a homemade rest that accomodates leverguns (so do some of the LeadSled models) so you don't even have to move the gun to work the lever.
Using such a setup, I sit the newbie down at the bench, with hearing protectors on, and adjust the rest so the gun is properly aimed at the 6" 50-yard flip-up gong, which of course seems so far away and tiny to them. After demonstrating the controls and so on, I fire a shot, and 'bang-pling' the target is hit. During the nine remaining in the magazine, they will typically hit at least seven times, often all nine. I hand them another loaded magazine, and with that one, they usually hit 9 or 10 shots out of 10. They typically look at me as if to say "is this all there is to it...?", so I usually say "let's try a bolt-action" and we shoot a Ruger 77/22, which I have a NECG aperture sight on. It is a bit more difficult for them to use, but they are ready for the challenge, and eagerly proceed. After that, we go to a Ruger 10/22 with a Bushnell 4x Sportview on it, that is a bit harder yet, but mounted higher than most 'experienced shooters' would prefer, so requires less 'scrunching down'. They usually hit 8 or 9 out of 10 with that one, only faster.
From there, we progress to .22 LR handguns, then .38 Specials in a .357 Mag levergun, and so on, until at the 4-hour mark, they pick up a Ruger Bisley .44 Mag, and hit a 5-gallon bucket at 50 yards. At that point, I can tell from their wide grin that I have successfully gotten them 'hooked' on shooting...


- (Unfortunately, many times the same 'newbie' will be handed that .44 Mag as their first gun to shoot, I guess so the 'instructor' can show how macho they are, and the noise and recoil will leave them flinching and unable to shoot accurately enough to enjoy shooting, so they will often not come back for another session.)
- First - overcome their fear of not being able to hit the target
Second - overcome the distraction and fear of noise
Third - overcome the distraction and fear of recoil
Back to the 'Newbie Levergun' - I still found some shooters distracted by the noise, and having to wear hearing protectors, so I wanted to see how they'd do with less noise. I tried the Aguila SSS ammo, and it is very quiet, but it is also very expensive, and we may shoot several hundred rounds before progressing to centerfire, so I went to a suppressor-shoot held locally, and watched (and listened) to the newbie shooters there. The only noise aside from firing-pins impacted by hammers, was steel targets impacted by bullets, and I must say the ability to converse easily without shouting over hearing protectors was nice, as was the total absense of flinching and distraction due to noise.
So . . . after about a year of waiting for paperwork . . . I got a new barrel for the Ruger 96/22 (it actually was made for a 10/22, and works perfectly on them as well - I had to hand-file a second extractor groove for the dual-extractor of the 96/22, which took about 15 minutes).

It is about the perfect newbie levergun, and will be my new walkabout gun for awhile, as well. Even bulk-pack .22's are VERY quiet due to the design (Thompson Machine 'Operative' model), so I don't have to use subsonics, but if I do use subsonics, it is ghostly quiet).
Here's a link to the suppressor - http://www.thompsonmachine.net/?page_id=14 (scroll down the page).
Now, if I could just get it equipped with a collapsable-stock like the AR-15 ones, so it could fit even the youngsters, that would be even better.

I know it lacks the historic lines and grace of a Marlin 39A, but my priority was to set up the ideal 'newbie' levergun, and I think it will be just about perfect.