Three deer hunters in our family this year...
After the past year's trading and fooling around, I wound up with my choices discussed earlier in the thread, and here are the two my kids will use:
My 'main' one - the Ruger 96/44 because it is easy to unload for crossing roads, coming in the house, etc., and just because I
like it...
My 'rain' one - the Ruger 77/44 because it's not got any blued steel or wood other than the sights.
Both the above guns have 1:20 twist, too, in case I ever decide to use heavy bullets vs. the 240 grain ones.
My 'updated' one - since I had to fork over my original 1894 to my son when he got his first deer with it, I got a stainless 1894, and it's not killed a buck yet, so I need to give it a chance.
My son's - (and formerly my) Marlin 1894 has the honor of getting the biggest buck (10 points) our family has gotten, and he'll use that this year. He can't get a buck with it (Ha!

) because he already got one during bow season.
My daughter's - she used to fear .44 Recoil, but traded in her .357 on a Puma 16" .44 Mag; she hits well with it, so should be good to go!
For Muzzleloader Season, here's what we'll use:
Me the Savage ML-II, my daughter the Black Diamond, and my son the Encore.